Jewel in the Sea

Kate Denny from Jewel In the Sea Nantucket

Custom Services & Repairs 

Here at Jewel in the Sea we believe that no task is too big or too small.  Let us assist in bringing your prized heirloom piece of jewelry to its original state, repair a loved everyday jewelry essential or create a new piece to symbolize new memories, all on site. We have an extensive in house inventory of diamonds and can work with any budget in finding that perfect engagement ring. Jack offers watch repairs, including battery changing, band sizing, and complete overhauls. He can also add a personalized engraving to a wide variety of pieces. Kate, our Graduate Gemologist, would love to appraise your jewelry for insurance coverage, estate affairs or to fulfill the curiosity of a recently found treasure.  Megan is continuing the store tradition of ear piercing, starting from ages five and up.  We love seeing our customers pop in when in town for complimentary cleaning of any jewelry pieces purchased in store. 


Jack Pearson Jewel In The Sea Nantucket
Kete Denny Jewel In The Sea Nantucket

Ear Piercings

Jewel in the Sea provides Ear Piercing Services by Appointment. Offering a variety of styles, all of our choices come sterile and are of surgical-grade stainless steel. The process is easy and includes Cleaning Solution and instructions on safe-care maintenance of your new earrings. We truly enjoy providing this memorable service and do so with care and ease. Request an appointment today! All appointment requests will be confirmed via email or phone depending on availability.

  • We pierce ears only. Cartilage and seconds, thirds, fourths.

  • Several styles to choose from.

  • Children under the age of 18 need a parent/guardian’s permission.

  • Sorry, we do not pierce children under the age of 5.

  • Walk ins are welcome but appointments are encouraged to ensure availability.

  • Price is $75 – includes earrings and cleaning solution.

Jewel In The Sea Nantucket Ear Piercing

Jewel In the Sea Nantucket Appraisals

Appraisals by Jewel in the Sea

If you are in need of a jewelry or watch appraisal, Jewel in the Sea is happy to assist you. Whether you are looking to insure a new piece or learn the value or an old one you’ve come to the right place. We utilize current market values of precious metals and gems, as well as gemological tools to aide in our analysis. Meet with Kate, our certified Graduate Gemologist, to determine the best type of appraisal to suit your needs. Our appraisal services range from gem identification to any and all insurance and estate appraisals. It is best to bring supporting documentation that you may have of your appraisal item (certificates, purchase receipts, warranties etc.). The finished appraisal is a comprehensive bound report outlining key details of your appraised item and value. Appraisals may take 10-14 business days to prepare depending.